What Do Mobsters Think of Goodfellas?

What Do Mobsters Think of “Goodfellas”?

“Goodfellas,” directed by Martin Scorsese and released in 1990, is often regarded as one of the greatest films ever made, especially within the crime genre. The film, based on the true story of mobster-turned-informant Henry Hill, offers a gritty and realistic portrayal of life in the Mafia. Its influence on popular culture is undeniable, and it has set the standard for subsequent gangster films. But while critics and audiences have lauded the film for its authenticity, there’s an intriguing question: What do real-life mobsters think of “Goodfellas”?

The Impact of “Goodfellas” on the Public’s Perception of the Mafia

“Goodfellas” was a groundbreaking film that changed the way the public perceived the Mafia. Before its release, the image of the mob in popular culture was largely shaped by films like “The Godfather,” which presented a more romanticized and honorable view of organized crime. “Goodfellas,” however, stripped away the glamour and presented a raw, unfiltered look at the day-to-day lives of mobsters.

• A Shift in Perception: The film portrayed the Mafia as a brutal, often chaotic organization where betrayal and violence were commonplace. The romanticism associated with the mob was replaced with a sense of realism that was both shocking and compelling. For many, “Goodfellas” provided a more accurate representation of the Mafia, one that highlighted the grim reality of life in organized crime.
• The Response from Real Mobsters: The film’s portrayal of the Mafia was so accurate that it resonated deeply with those who had lived the life. Many real-life mobsters recognized themselves in the characters and situations depicted in the film, leading to a mix of admiration and unease.

Reactions from Former Mobsters

Over the years, several former mobsters have spoken out about their thoughts on “Goodfellas.” Their reactions provide valuable insight into how accurately the film depicts life in the Mafia and what it got right—and wrong—about the criminal underworld.

Henry Hill’s Perspective

Henry Hill, the real-life inspiration for the character portrayed by Ray Liotta, was heavily involved in the making of “Goodfellas.” After becoming an informant and entering the witness protection program, Hill worked closely with author Nicholas Pileggi and director Martin Scorsese to bring his story to life.

• Accuracy and Authenticity: Hill often praised “Goodfellas” for its accuracy, noting that the film captured the essence of his life in the Mafia. He was impressed by how Scorsese and Liotta depicted his experiences, from the allure of the mob lifestyle to the paranoia and violence that ultimately led to his downfall.
• A Reflection of Reality: According to Hill, many scenes in the film were almost identical to how they happened in real life. The infamous “funny how?” scene with Joe Pesci’s character, Tommy DeVito, was based on a real conversation, and the chaotic, high-energy atmosphere of the mob world was depicted with an authenticity that Hill found striking.

Michael Franzese’s Take

Michael Franzese, a former caporegime in the Colombo crime family, has also shared his thoughts on “Goodfellas.” After leaving the Mafia and turning his life around, Franzese became an author and motivational speaker. He has frequently commented on the accuracy of various mob films, including “Goodfellas.”

• Praising the Realism: Franzese has often praised “Goodfellas” for its realistic portrayal of the Mafia. He noted that the film accurately captured the everyday life of mobsters, from the way they interacted with each other to the code of silence they upheld. According to Franzese, “Goodfellas” was one of the few films that didn’t glamorize the mob but instead showed the harsh realities of the lifestyle.
• Depicting the Downside: One aspect of the film that Franzese particularly appreciated was its portrayal of the downside of being in the Mafia. The constant fear of betrayal, the inevitability of violence, and the ultimate consequences of a life of crime were all themes that resonated with him. For Franzese, “Goodfellas” was a film that got it right, showing both the allure and the dangers of the mob life.

Sammy “The Bull” Gravano’s View

Sammy “The Bull” Gravano, the former underboss of the Gambino crime family, is another high-profile mobster who has spoken about “Goodfellas.” Gravano, who became one of the most infamous turncoats in Mafia history, offered a unique perspective on the film.

• A Mixed Reaction: Gravano has expressed mixed feelings about “Goodfellas.” While he acknowledged the film’s accuracy in depicting the Mafia’s operations and the personalities involved, he was less enthusiastic about how certain aspects of mob life were portrayed. For Gravano, some scenes felt exaggerated or dramatized for effect, although he recognized that this was likely done to make the film more entertaining for a general audience.
• Personal Reflections: Gravano also noted that watching “Goodfellas” brought back memories of his own life in the Mafia. The film’s depiction of the loyalty, betrayal, and violence that defined the mob world resonated with him, but it also served as a reminder of the choices he made and the consequences that followed.

Reactions from Lesser-Known Mobsters

In addition to the high-profile figures like Hill, Franzese, and Gravano, there have been numerous lesser-known mobsters who have shared their thoughts on “Goodfellas.” These individuals, who may not have achieved the same level of infamy, nonetheless offer valuable insights into how the film is perceived by those who lived the life.

• A Sense of Nostalgia: For some former mobsters, “Goodfellas” evokes a sense of nostalgia for a time when they were at the height of their power. The film’s depiction of the camaraderie, the rules, and the lifestyle resonates with their own memories of being part of the Mafia. For these individuals, “Goodfellas” is a reminder of both the highs and lows of their criminal past.
• Respect for the Craft: Many real-life mobsters have expressed respect for the craftsmanship that went into making “Goodfellas.” From the performances of the actors to the direction of Scorsese, they recognize the film as a masterful depiction of their world. Even if they don’t always agree with how certain events or characters are portrayed, there is an acknowledgment that “Goodfellas” is a work of art that captures the essence of the Mafia.

The Influence of “Goodfellas” on Mob Culture

“Goodfellas” didn’t just reflect the Mafia; it also influenced how the mob and its members are perceived, both by the public and within the organization itself. The film’s impact on mob culture is undeniable, and it has become a point of reference for many involved in organized crime.

• Shaping the Image of the Mob: For many, “Goodfellas” has become the definitive portrayal of the Mafia. Its influence extends beyond the screen, shaping the way people talk about and understand organized crime. Real-life mobsters have commented on how the film has influenced the public’s perception of the Mafia, sometimes to the point where people assume all mobsters behave like the characters in the movie.
• A Point of Pride: Some mobsters take pride in the fact that “Goodfellas” is based on real events and people from their world. They see the film as a representation of their lifestyle, albeit with some artistic license. The accuracy of the film, combined with its critical and commercial success, has led to a sense of pride among some former mobsters who feel that “Goodfellas” captures the essence of their lives.
• Inspiring a New Generation: “Goodfellas” has also had an impact on younger generations who are fascinated by the Mafia. The film’s portrayal of the mob as both alluring and dangerous has inspired countless discussions, analyses, and even a renewed interest in organized crime. For some, “Goodfellas” serves as both a cautionary tale and a blueprint for understanding the complexities of the Mafia.

The Legacy of “Goodfellas” in the Mafia

“Goodfellas” has left a lasting legacy, not only in the world of cinema but also within the Mafia itself. Its impact on how the mob is perceived and how it perceives itself is a testament to the film’s authenticity and power.

Continuing Relevance: “Goodfellas” remains relevant today, both as a piece of entertainment and as a document of Mafia life. It continues to be studied, discussed, and revered, not only by film enthusiasts but also by those who lived the life it portrays. Its impact on the Mafia and its portrayal in popular culture is enduring, making it a film that resonates far beyond its initial release.

A Cultural Touchstone: “Goodfellas” has become a cultural touchstone for both the public and the Mafia. It is frequently referenced in discussions about organized crime, and its influence can be seen in subsequent films, television shows, and even in the way real-life mobsters talk about their own experiences. The film’s legacy is one of authenticity, capturing the brutal reality of the Mafia while also acknowledging its allure.

A Reminder of the Past: For those who were part of the Mafia during the time depicted in “Goodfellas,” the film serves as a reminder of a bygone era. It captures a moment in time when the mob was at its peak, before the decline brought about by increased law enforcement pressure and the rise of RICO prosecutions. Watching “Goodfellas” is, for some, a way to relive those days, even as they recognize the darker aspects of their former lives.

Final Thoughts

“Goodfellas” remains relevant today, both as a piece of entertainment and as a document of Mafia life. It continues to be studied, discussed, and revered, not only by film enthusiasts but also by those who lived the life it portrays. Its impact on the Mafia and its portrayal in popular culture is enduring, making it a film that resonates far beyond its initial release.

For real-life mobsters, “Goodfellas” is a film that hits close to home. While some may view it with a sense of nostalgia or pride, others see it as a stark reminder of the violence, betrayal, and inevitable downfall that come with a life of crime. Regardless of their individual perspectives, most agree that “Goodfellas” captures the essence of the Mafia with an authenticity that few other films have matched. It is a film that has left an indelible mark on both the world of organized crime and the broader cultural landscape, solidifying its place as one of the most significant and influential films about the Mafia ever made.