What Do Mobsters Think of Goodfellas?

The reception of “Goodfellas” among actual mobsters has been mixed, with some appreciating its authenticity and others criticizing it for various reasons. Here’s a breakdown of the perspectives:

Appreciation for Authenticity

• Realism: Some mobsters and those familiar with organized crime have praised “Goodfellas” for its realistic portrayal of the life and culture within the mob. The film’s attention to detail, from the dialogue to the depiction of everyday mob life, resonated with those who experienced that world first-hand.
• Character Portrayals: The performances, particularly Joe Pesci’s portrayal of Tommy DeVito (based on real-life mobster Thomas DeSimone), have been noted for capturing the volatile and unpredictable nature of mobsters. Pesci’s character, despite being more compact in stature, effectively conveyed the intimidation and danger that many mobsters exude.

Criticism and Controversy

• Glamorization vs. Reality: While “Goodfellas” is lauded for its authenticity, some argue that it glamorizes mob life, focusing on the excitement and power while downplaying the consequences and the brutal reality of the criminal activities. The film’s stylish presentation, coupled with its humor and charismatic performances, can be seen as romanticizing a dangerous and unethical lifestyle.
• Exaggeration and Inaccuracy: Certain mobsters have criticized the film for exaggerating or inaccurately portraying events and characters for dramatic effect. They argue that some scenes, relationships, and personalities are heightened or modified, which, while effective for a cinematic narrative, don’t always align with the actualities of mob life.
• Personal Reactions: Individuals who knew the real people depicted in the film, like Henry Hill, have had varied reactions, with some stating that the film accurately captured the personalities and events, while others felt it took liberties with the truth.

Impact on Public Perception

• Influence on Mafia Image: “Goodfellas” has significantly influenced the public’s perception of the Mafia. It presented a gritty, unglamorous view of mob life that contrasted with the more polished and romanticized portrayals in earlier films like “The Godfather.” This shift has been acknowledged by mob members as closer to their reality, even if it simultaneously contributed to a mythologized image of the Mafia in popular culture.
• Cultural Icon: The film has become a cultural touchstone, with its lines, scenes, and characters deeply embedded in the public’s view of the Mafia. This widespread recognition is something that real-life mobsters are acutely aware of, and their views on the film can be influenced by how it affects their own legacy and public image.

In summary, the reaction to “Goodfellas” within the criminal underworld is as complex and varied as the personalities it depicts. While there is an appreciation for the film’s craft and a recognition of its realistic elements, there are also concerns about accuracy and the potential for glorification of the mob lifestyle.